Always on My Mind by Kelsey Painter

Tessa Gallagher knows who her soulmate is. She went to a past life regressionist to find out. Unfortunately, it’s her ex-girlfriend. The same ex who wasn’t ready to come out after a year together. Now, they don’t even live in the same city. Tessa has to move on. But she can’t seem to forget.
Jamie Hupp is back in London. She’s come back after three years to play for the newly promoted Stanmore FC women’s team. She left after Tessa broke her heart, but when a coach made things uncomfortable for her, Jamie found her way back home. And back to Tessa.
After all these years, Jamie should be able to stand up to her perfectionist father, who controls her footballing career and her public image. He certainly doesn’t want her to be the stereotype of a gay woman athlete. But if Jamie wants another shot with Tessa, she’ll have to confront him or risk losing the love of her life.
Despite knowledge of their deeper connection, Tessa is slow to trust that Jamie will get there. Jamie was the one who ran away in their past lives, after all. And Tessa remembers the hurt. She knows she can’t love Jamie out of being afraid.
Can they find a way to be together? Or will they have to wait for the next lifetime?