Maverick by Susie McIver

Sometimes life just wasn’t fair. She’s Amish, and I’m Maverick, and nowhere near perfect.
Loving Rebecca Cover was both the easiest and the hardest thing I ever did.
Falling in love with her was effortless, but everything else was complicated. As an Amish woman under my protection, Rebecca’s innocence and beauty were undeniable, even beneath her modest attire. It was only my willpower that kept me from crossing boundaries. And she was making it harder and harder.
I had no willpower when it came to Maverick.
He was assigned to guard me, but who would guard him from my affection? After my family was brutally murdered, I was sent to Maverick for protection, fearing someone might realize they hadn’t finished the job. Now, I must return to keep my friends safe and prevent them from lying about my survival. Why would anyone want my entire family dead?